‘One nation, one election’ not feasible now: EC sources; Modi govt forms panel to study feasibility

As Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Wednesday held a meeting of various parties to discuss 'one nation, one election', or simultaneous parliamentary and assembly polls, Election Commission sources claimed that the idea is not feasible as of now.

This comes in the backdrop of the government having decided to form a committee to study the feasibility of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's "One Nation, One Election", said Union Minister Rajnath Singh said after Prime Minister Narendra Modi's all-party meeting on Wednesday.

Rajnath Singh alleged that several parties supported the idea though five key parties, including the Congress, however skipped the meet. Mamata Banerjee expressed reservations about the modality of such a project and Mayawati mocked the government. Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav and DMK chief MK Stalin also stayed away. Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, former Chief Minister and Telugu Desam Party chief N Chandrababu Naidu and Telangana Chief Minister K Chandresekhar Rao sent representatives.

A former Chief Election Commissioner also said the proposal has serious demerits.

A top Election Commission source said that if the idea was feasible, then the poll panel would have held simultaneous assembly polls this year only along with the Lok Sabha polls.

The Election Commission had conducted the general elections in seven phases for the 542 Lok Sabha seats between April 11 to May 19. Results of the election were declared on May 23.

The source also contended that taking case the law and order situation during simultaneous polls can be very challenging as the number of central paramilitary forces is limited.

He also said that there are over 90 crore voters across the country and to prepare the logistics for simultaneous polls can be very tough, as of now.

The remarks of the top Election Commission sources comes after Modi held meeting with the Presidents of several political parties during the day in Parliament to discuss the idea of 'one nation, one election'.

Former Chief Election Commissioner S.Y. Quraishi said the biggest issue in this is federalism.
"The national political considerations cannot subjugate the state's interests. Besides frequent elections increase accountability of elected representatives who are notorious for not showing their faces for five years after the elections," he said.