Imran Khan stands completely isolated even as Pakistan grapples with constitutional crisis
“With parliamentary process pulverised on orders of a leader who continues to hold it in deep contempt, Pakistan has been thrown into dark abyss of a constitutional crisis,” an English daily observed
Pakistan’s Prime Minister Imran Khan is in an existential crisis that pushed him personally into a political quagmire. His stature worsened further following the crucial observation by the Chief Justice of Pakistan (CPJ) Umar Ata Bandial during the hearing of a suo moto matter following the dismissal of National Assembly of Pakistan on Sunday by the President Arif Alvi on his advice that the National Assembly (NA) Speaker erred in rejecting the no-confidence motion.
The meaning is clear that reference to Article 5 of the Constitution of Islamic Republic of Pakistan is incongruent.
The CJP’s remarks was in the midst of hearing of the suo moto case related to the constitutional dilemma following the ruling by the NA deputy speaker Qasim Suri and the subsequent dissolution of the lower house on the advice of PM Imran Khan.
Incidentally, NA Speaker Asad Qaiser was reportedly unwilling to a ruling as per Article 5.
Earlier, Attorney General Khalid Javed too had told TV anchor Humid Mir in Geo News programmed Capital Talk that voting was a must on the no-confidence resolution against the PM Imran Khan on April 3 under the Constitution.
The deputy speaker Qasim Suri, a member of ruling PTI, chaired the session and promulgated dissolution of NA. He blocked the confidence motion that Khan had widely been expected to lose. Hence the ruling assuming that a ‘foreign conspiracy’ was behind the no-trust motion was considered unconstitutional by many.
Heading a five-member larger bench that included Justice Ijazul Ahsan, Justice Mohammad Ali Mazhar, Justice Munib Akhtar and Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail, the SCP is looking into the matter in terms of Article 63(A) of the Constitution that suggests disqualification on grounds of defection for not obeying the parliamentary party directions in the election of the prime minister, chief minister or vote of confidence or no confidence or money bill etc
Former PM Nawaz Sharif said on Sunday that Prime Minister Imran Khan and all characters involved in the "conspiracy" against the nation are guilty of high treason and should be tried under Article 6 of the Constitution. He tweeted in chaste Urdu, which, translated freely, read, “Today, a man obsessed with power trampled on the Constitution. Imran Khan, who puts his ego before the country and the nation, and all the conspiratorial characters involved in this conspiracy are guilty of serious treason to which Article 6 applies. Abuse of Pakistan and desecration of the Constitution will be taken into account,” he said.
Pakistan People’s Party chairman Bilawal Bhutto Zardari ridiculed Imran Khan, saying that instead of ‘playing till the last ball, he had run away with the wickets’. He said that the president, prime minister, NA speaker, deputy speaker and anybody involved in this act on Sunday had committed high treason.
Pakistan’s internationally well-known TV personality Amir Liaquat Hossain and a member of PTI snapped fingers at Khan, “I would like to say that the Prime Minister has proved that the opposition was right. I am announcing to leave the PTI, which has deviated from the constitution? The decision will be made by the court but unfortunately this game was played to remove General Qamar Bajwa”.
A leading English daily made a blistering attack on Khan: “With the parliamentary process pulverised on the orders of a leader who continues to hold it in deep contempt, Pakistan has been thrown into the dark abyss of a constitutional crisis. It seems, in retrospect, that the captain had planned to play this dastardly card all along. It came as a rude shock: it takes quite the fall for a self-proclaimed ‘fighter’ to display such unsportsmanlike behaviour. By tearing up the rules of the game instead of ‘playing till the last ball’.”
Whether the NA session is reconvened to pave the way for a no trust motion remains to be seen. The defeat of ruling PTI-led government is certain as support from 172 NA members in favour of the government is almost impossible while more than 190 members are likely to vote for the motion.
Imran Khan’s grip on power has steadily weakened over the past two weeks. His rhetoric on the alleged role of foreign powers in Pakistan’s domestic affairs has proved vacuous. Even many in his party Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaaf are not convinced that the USA backs the no-confidence motion, hatching a grand conspiracy to remove him.
He has stated, “They are against me because I am against corruption” and “I am being removed because I am standing against the West, particularly America, for pursuing an independent foreign policy”.
The high-powered National Security Council (NSC) headed by PM had sat to discuss the so-called diplomatic cable which, the PTI government claimed, had evidence of the US plot seeking a regime change in Pakistan. The NSC decided to issue a demarche to the USA. But the Pakistan’s military top brass pooh-poohed the allegation.
The isolation of Imran Khan is more than evident.
Views are personal
Published: 05 Apr 2022, 7:02 PM