India

Mirror, mirror on the wall, who is the biggest liar of them all?

PM Modi on Sunday virtually called President of India and his own Home Minister, who had declared in Parliament that NRC would be rolled out across country,liars. Read reactions to his bizarre speech

Barely a month ago, the BJP manifesto for Jharkhand claimed that rolling out the National Register of Citizens in the country was a BJP promise and achievement. The President of India Ramnath Kovind had also spoken of the NRC getting rolled out in the country. So did the Home Minister Amit Shah.

But on Sunday, PM Modi said at Ramlila Maidan that since 2014, his Government had never even discussed the NRC.

Read some of the reactions to his claim:

· The PM's election campaign speech in Delhi today is full of untruths, half-truths and misleading statements. Whether it be the NRC, CAA or detention camps, the facts are to the contrary. Leaving his "facts" aside, there is nothing in Modi's election speech which makes any material difference to the situation. Nothing short of a clear-cut announcement of cancelling all-India NRC, announced by President & HM in Parliament & withdrawal of CAA, will make a difference.: Sitaram Yechury

· On the PM's speech today that there's been "no discussion" about an NRC: a reminder that the ongoing National Population Register (NPR), for the first time, now asks you for parents' date and place of birth - coincidentally, exactly what an NRC would ask.: Gautam Bhatia

· PM says in the Ramlila Grounds - there are no detention centres in India. His Govt told Rajya Sabha on 27 th November 2019 that 28 people died in Detention Camps in Assam. Are you correct PM or your Home Minister?: Manish Tewary

· PM of India is contradicting President of India. PM said: "Since 2014, my Govt has never discussed even the word #NRC" but on 20.6.2019 Pres said: "My (Modi) Govt has decided to implement the process of NRC..." You assured "my 130 cr Indians" that "my govt never discussed #NRC since 2014", and that Oppn is spreading a lie.

Published: 23 Dec 2019, 8:12 AM IST

Q: How did NRC figure in BJP's 2019 LS Manifesto?

Did No.2 (Party President) not consult you??? : Sudheendra Kulkarni

· PM claimed "There are no detention centres in India" But, as per your own Govt's 2019 Model Detention Manual, "Every city or district, which has an immigration check post, MUST HAVE A DETENTION CENTRE.: Sudheendra Kulkarni

· The assurance of Prime Minister on NRC sounds hollow, because HM Mr. Shah contradicts this very claim. It is worth recollecting the claims made during the time of demonetization; "give me 50 days", ending counterfeits, black money, terrorism etc. Well, we all know what happened.: Pinarayi Vijayan

· A month ago, #NRC was in the BJP's election manofesto for the Jharkhand elections. So who's the liar? Obviously, the prime one.: Ranjona Banerjee

Published: 23 Dec 2019, 8:12 AM IST

· First they said CAB will be followed by NRC.

Then they said CAA has nothing to do with NRC.

Now they are said they never said anything about NRC.

So long as we have CAA, they always have the “Muslim filter” to carry out selective NRC whenever they want. : Shivam Vij

· How much can a PM lie? Modi says there was never any plan to have a detention camp. In this report Minister of State for Home saying special facility for women and children! India's 1st Illegal Immigrant Detention Camp Size Of 7 Football Fields. : M.K. Venu

· I have few regrets in life. But one of them is that I wish I could lie even 1/10 th as brilliantly as PM Narendra Modi. But after today Mr Modi has reached a new Himalayan zenith in lying. I am dumbstruck with awe and admiration. Sir, you are a gold standard in bluffing.: Sanjay Jha

· "Process (of detention) will be managed by Foreigners Tribunals. Government has its own preparations to make. There's a legal process where FTs concerned. That process has started. Process has started in advance", declared Amit Shah in October, 2019 : Rupa Subramanya

· the NCR can be disguised as a NPR till 99% of the work is complete. A formal announcement is not necessary to carry forward the work until 2021. NCR is just a subset of the NPR where CAA act as a selective enabling filter: Sonali Ranade

· PM said that the Nationwide NRC country isn’t in the works at all. Only a day ago, the Union Ministry of Home Affairs released a document that gives concrete opinions about how the NRC will be implemented across the country.

Published: 23 Dec 2019, 8:12 AM IST

Follow us on: Facebook, Twitter, Google News, Instagram 

Join our official telegram channel (@nationalherald) and stay updated with the latest headlines

Published: 23 Dec 2019, 8:12 AM IST