US expert slams Trudeau's allegations against India as "shameless and cynical"
Michael Rubin, however, warned against official US involvement in the Khalistan controversy, while urging responsible leadership on all sides
A US expert has termed Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau's claim of a "potential link" between Indian government agents and the killing of a Khalistani leader as a "shameless and cynical action" and urged the United States to not be any part of the controversy.
Participating in a panel discussion at the Hudson Institute think-tank, Michael Rubin, senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, claimed that Trudeau is playing into the hands of people who are looking at the Khalistani movement to boost their egos and profits.
Canada and India have expelled a senior diplomat each after Trudeau alleged the involvement of "agents of the Indian government" in the killing of prominent Sikh separatist leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar, 45, in Surrey in June, claims strongly rejected by India as "absurd" and "motivated".
Nijjar, the chief of the banned Khalistan Tiger Force (KTF) and one of India's most-wanted terrorists, carried a cash reward of Rs 10 lakh on his head. He was shot dead by two unidentified gunmen outside a gurudwara in Surrey, in the western Canadian province of British Columbia on 18 June.
What Rubin said was striking about Trudeau's "shameless and cynical action" is that while Trudeau was making a statement on this now, the killing of Karima Baluch that was carried out allegedly with Pakistani assistance is also a police matter and has not been taken up by the Candian prime minister's office.
"So, the question then becomes why the discrepancy if not populist political posturing?... That might help Justin Trudeau in the long term but that's not what leadership is. We really need our politicians on both sides of the aisle here, and in Canada, (there is a) need to be much more responsible because they're playing with fire," he said.
It seems, Rubin said, that some outside hands are trying to revive the Khalistan movement.
"I don't think it will work," he said, adding also that he would not want the US to give legitimacy to such "cynical manoeuvres by outside powers".
"It would be a mistake to suddenly see a separatist movement and argue that this is legitimate. And I worry less so with the United States but more so with what we see in Canada right now, with Justin Trudeau, (with) that same knee-jerk reaction playing into the hands of people who are looking at the Khalistani movement as a movement for ego, a movement for profit and for politics," Rubin added.
After Trudeau's remarks in Parliament, Canadian foreign minister Melanie Joly confirmed that she had ordered the expulsion of "a senior Indian diplomat".
Reacting sharply to the allegations and to Joly's remarks, India firmly rejected Trudeau's claims, calling them "absurd and motivated". The ministry of external affairs (MEA) also asked a Canadian diplomat to leave India within the next five days.
Jassee Singh, founder and chairman of Sikhs of America, said the Khalistani movement does not represent the voice of the majority of Sikhs in the US.
"Sikhs in India are not in favour of Khalistan. Today, Sikhs are in the Indian Army defending the nation, whether it's against China or Pakistan," he said.
"There are 1 million Sikhs living here (in the US) and only a few of them, a very, very small percentage shows up for protests demanding Khalistan," he said.
Dinsha Mistree, research fellow at the Hoover Institution, said that if Canada keeps pushing this narrative, then "we can see some big challenges there".
He also underlined the importance of intelligence sharing.
"For me, it is just very surprising," Mistree said. "Again, the San Francisco consulate is not too far away. I don't think any arrests have been made since this consulate was vandalised twice. If you don't stop these smaller things, (then there is a) danger that they might snowball into bigger things."
In July, India's consulate in San Francisco came under attack from Khalistan supporters, who tried to set the diplomatic facility on fire, in the second such act of violence within months.
A video by Khalistan supporters, dated 2 July, was posted on X (formerly Twitter) and showed the act of arson at the Indian consulate. The video, with the words "violence begets violence" emblazoned over it, also showed news articles related to the death of Nijjar.