Nation

Deepathoon row: SC grants one-time permission to light lamp atop Thiruparankundram hill on Nov 24

Supreme Court allows limited access but makes it clear that it is not a final decision on customary, religious or proprietary right

A temple priest in Madurai distributes sweets to devotees after the SC verdict
A temple priest in Madurai distributes sweets to devotees after the SC verdict Photo: PTI

The Supreme Court on Friday, 20 November, permitted the lighting of the traditional Karthigai Deepam lamp on November 24 as a one-time measure at the ‘deepathoon’, a stone pillar atop Thiruparankundram hill in Tamil Nadu's Madurai.

A bench of justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi said only authorised persons from the temple administration and government officials can go for the lamp lighting and ordered authorities to deploy necessary security if required.

It restrained public from going to the place and said no procession, public congregation, slogan-raising or demonstration shall be allowed during the ceremony.

The top court, however, stayed portions of the judgement that had upheld the direction to restore the practice of lighting the lamp at the spot.

"We deem it appropriate to mould the interim relief in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case … This permission is granted as a measure of temporary arrangement and not in recognition or enforcement of any asserted customary, religious or proprietary right," the bench said.

While directing that no member of the general public would accompany the authorised team to the Deepathoon, the apex court ordered that the district administration, in consultation with the authorities concerned, shall settle the timing, route of access, duration and other incidental arrangements, keeping in view the requirements of public safety, fire prevention, archaeological protection and maintenance of peace.

"The authorised team shall leave the site immediately upon completion of the ceremony, without leaving behind any temporary article or installation.

"The Archaeological Survey of India shall prescribe appropriate conditions for the protection and preservation of the monument and its surroundings," it said.

The top court clarified that existing religious observances at the customary locations shall continue undisturbed.

"Equally, the lawful religious activities, access and enjoyment of the Dargah and other institutions shall not be interfered with in any manner. The present arrangement shall not confer upon any person an additional right of entry, occupation or control over any portion of the hill," it said.

The interim permission comes amid a dispute between Hindu worshippers and the Hazrat Sultan Sikandar Badusha Auliya dargah over ownership of the hilltop and the location of the ritual.

The apex court said the permission granted by it cannot be relied on by any party as evidence of any established custom.

"We make it abundantly clear that the present arrangement does not proceed upon any finding that the stone pillar is, or has historically been, a place of customary religious observance.

"The limited accommodation made today is not a determination of the dispute; it is an arrangement made precisely because the dispute remains to be determined,” the court said.

The Karthigai Deepam controversy at the Arulmigu Subramaniaswamy temple in Madurai centres on a dispute over where and by whom the lamp should be lit on the Thiruparankundram hill.

For decades, the deepam was lit at the Deepa Mandapam, near the Uchipillaiyar temple on the lower slopes.

Hindu groups had sought permission to light the lamp at the stone lamp pillar located higher up the hill approximately 50 metres from the dargah.

(With agency inputs)