Opinion

Curbing the church, hitting the people

Ban on using foreign funds for anything interpretable as conversion creates a chilling effect on open religious practice

Representational image
Representational image IANS

The church has strongly protested the latest FCRA tweaks, seeing them as a backdoor attempt to seize control of properties built over decades with foreign donations.

These changes, notified recently in June 2026 and building on earlier amendments, require NGOs to specify exact activities, geographical areas, disclose social media accounts, websites, and publications, while barring political content.

More critically, provisions around license non-renewal or cancellation let authorities take over assets funded by foreign contributions, manage or sell them, often without easy judicial recourse. Church leaders call this legalised loot.

The Catholic Bishops’ Conference of India has raised grave concerns, labelling the moves dangerous and unconstitutional.

They’ve called for a national day of prayer today, 28 June, urging Catholics to pray for the church’s continued service to the poor.
Other leaders say it’s a stealthy way to grab schools, hospitals, orphanages, and church buildings that serve millions, especially Dalits, tribals, and marginalised communities.

From the FCRA data and patterns, over 20,000 licenses have been canceled or not renewed since around 2014, with a heavy impact on Christian-linked organisations.

Groups like Compassion International lost registration years ago, cutting support to over a hundred and forty-seven thousand children and hundreds of churches.

World Vision, Evangelical Fellowship of India, and others have faced similar crackdowns.

The new rules tighten this further by limiting what foreign money can fund — explicitly barring proselytization or conversion activities, while allowing religious education, cultural preservation, and charity. Critics say the definitions are vague, leaving room for selective enforcement.

Churches argue these rules bypass proper scrutiny. Instead of transparent debate or judicial oversight, executive discretion grows.

Properties bought or built with overseas funds could vest with the government upon any lapse, even technical ones.
This hits hard because many Christian institutions rely on foreign partners for funding education, healthcare, and social work where government reach is limited.

The church runs tens thousands of schools and hospitals, often in remote or poor areas, serving people regardless of faith, and losing these assets wouldn’t just affect Christians — it would disrupt services for entire communities.

The harsh impacts are already visible in places where licenses were suspended.

In one Hyderabad school case, fees were introduced after funding dried up, causing over a hundred students from poor families to drop out.
Staff layoffs in large charities have halted programs across multiple states.
If scaled up through these new rules, the fallout could be massive: closures of orphanages, reduced medical camps, shuttered hostels for tribal students, and struggling rural development projects.

Administrative costs are already capped at twenty percent, squeezing operations. Adding mandatory disclosures and activity restrictions raises compliance burdens, especially for smaller faith-based groups without big legal teams.

Leaders worry this creates fear and self-censorshi — NGOs might avoid any advocacy touching social justice or minority rights, fearing it gets labeled political.

The expansion of who counts as a “key functionary” and demands for online transparency add layers of surveillance.

Published: undefined

Constitutionally, the church points to Articles 25 and 26 guaranteeing religious freedom and the right to manage institutions, plus Article 300A on property rights. They say seizing assets without due process violates natural justice.

Government says it hasevery right to track foreign money and stop misuse for conversions or anti-national activities, and there are a plethora of laws and regulations to check this, catch culprits, and punish them.

The government frames it as transparency and national security, not targeting any faith, yet the disproportionate effect on Christian organisations — who receive overseas support from common Christians including NRIs,  missionary societies and global charities — fuels suspicions of bias, especially under a Hindu nationalist framework.

The protest day is  a defence of decades of institution-building as Missionaries and local Christians have poured resources into remote areas long before independence, creating lasting infrastructure.

Weapsing rules now, without broad consultation, feels like moving the goalposts after the work is done.

If foreign funding dries up and assets get transferred, rebuilding that ecosystem becomes nearly impossible. Rural healthcare in particular could suffer, as many Christian hospitals serve where public facilities are stretched thin.

Smaller NGOs get hit hardest. Big ones might navigate paperwork, but grassroots groups running Bible studies alongside charity, or community programs with any evangelistic element, risk losing everything on technical violations.

The ban on using foreign funds for anything interpretable as conversion creates a chilling effect on open religious practice.
Broader ripple effects include strained international relations, with some US lawmakers already voicing concern.

Domestically, opposition parties call it an attack on minorities and civil society, comparing it to other controversial bills.

For the church, it’s mission of service is core to faith, not optional and stopping funds and threatening property undermines that calling.
Whether these tweaks genuinely curb abuse or quietly enable control remains debated.

What’s clear is the human cost if institutions built on trust and philanthropy get dismantled through regulatory means.
The national day of prayer today reflects deep anxiety but also resolve to protect a legacy of compassion that’s benefited India for generations.

Published: undefined

Join our official telegram channel (@nationalherald) and stay updated with the latest headlines

Published: undefined